As you can probably guess, I don’t read far-left Nation.Cymru unless my attention is drawn to a particularly noxious piece on that site. Which explains why I’m writing this.
◊
BACKGROUND
Nation.Cymru was set up in 2016 by author and journalist Ifan Morgan Jones. He left in 2022 to join S4C. As you might guess, he and I didn’t agree on much, but there was at least some kind of on/off dialogue. Even my comments to the site were published.
Before he left, public funding from the self-styled ‘Welsh Government’ (via the Books Council) started arriving.
In recent years the output from N.C has increased but as the quantity’s risen the quality’s gone in the opposite direction. For not only have journalistic standards fallen, but any pretence at impartiality has gone out the window.
It is now a ranting, frothing mouthpiece for the Plaid-Labour-Bluehair consensus of Corruption Bay. Divorced from the interests of most Welsh people, and antagonistic towards their genuine concerns.
The decline may have started with the arrival of Martin Shipton. I’m not saying he’s very left-wing, but he did have his front door kicked in earlier this year by officers from the Met Police anti-terrorism group, concerned that he might have links with the Chinese Communist Party (CCP).
But Shipton is not a well man, suffering as he does from RDS, or Reform Derangement Syndrome. This intellectually debilitating condition means that he sees Reform politicians and supporters everywhere, and feels compelled to share his obsession with the readers of N.C.
And the condition is clearly contagious. For other contributors to the site are also infected. Particularly Emily Price, who seems to have put her name to most of the recent pieces attacking Reform. It’s sad, and there’s no known cure for RDS.
Now don’t get me wrong, I’m not a member or supporter of Reform (it’s Brit and Unionist), and I could never see myself voting Reform, but that’s not the point.
If I’m paying – however unwillingly – for a site reporting on Welsh politics and current events then I’m entitled to expect that site to offer me a broad range of views, opinions, and interpretations. Nation.Cymru fails abysmally.
◊
‘WE KNOW WHAT YOU DID IN THE WAR’
The recent N.C piece I want to start with appeared on Monday last week, after the Remembrance Day ceremonies the previous day. It’s headed: “Reform MS ‘whitewashing her past’ in Remembrance Day video“. (Seeing that headline one might expect salacious gossip of the kind served up by the old News of the World.)
Note that whitewashing her past appears in quotes, for even though the article was by Shipton those remarks, and other contributions, came from Jeff Jones, former Labour leader of Bridgend council.
Normally, Jeff’s not a bad old stick, he gets in touch now and again, but here I’m afraid he’s gone over the top. For first, he attacks Reform MS Christiana Emsley for, basically, being Romanian! On the grounds that the country of her birth . . .
. . . provided the second-biggest Axis army on the Eastern Front after Nazi Germany,” . . .“They massacred 260,000 Jews. She is whitewashing her past. It’s bonkers.”
But how is that her past? She was born long after WWII; and even if her granny had personally executed thousands, no blame could attach to the MS for Fflint Wrecsam.
I got in touch with Jeff Jones, telling him I thought it was unfair to attack Christiana Emsley for what some in her country had done in WWII. He responded:
Romania is interesting because of the division in that country about Antonescu. War criminal for the left. Great patriot for the right. It still affects Romanian politics.
But many countries in Eastern Europe are divided by WWII, and those divisions linger. It’s what the CIA and NATO exploited to break up Jugoslavia. While in Ukraine there are many who still revere Stepan Bandera, who collaborated with the Nazis and whose followers committed atrocities against Jews, Poles, and others.
Post war Bandera lived in Munich, and his network within Ukraine was very helpful to Western intelligence agencies. He was supposedly poisoned by the KGB in 1959.

I also contacted Christiana Emsley; she is genuinely concerned that this article, linking her with the Nazi regime, puts a target on her back. Given the number of nutters hunting ‘fascists’ she’s right to feel uneasy. These extremists seem to be ignored or excused by the mainstream media and organs like Nation.Cymru.
We’re expected to believe that the only danger comes from the ‘far-night’.
◊
‘I KNEW A BLOKE . . . ‘
This section of the N.C article is perhaps even more bizarre. For it seems to criticise three Reform MSs for attending a Remembrance Day event.
Mr Jones also accused Reform MSs Francesca O’Brien, Steven Rodaway and Art Wright of seeking to make political capital out of Remembrance Day.
For a start, the powers that be – and here I’m not referring to our politicians – are psyching us up for war, so are we to believe that they weren’t making political capital out of Remembrance Day?
Jeff Jones had this to say about the three:
They really are a joke. Look at her medals for being in the cadets. Wright was a tank transporter guy. Rodaway reached captain after 10 years in the army.
With the cadet medals, he may have a point, though the local cadets always attend on Remembrance Sunday. As for the men in the photograph, both served in the army.
Yet Jones tries to belittle the service of MS Art Wright by dismissing him as a “tank transporter guy“. Isn’t that important? While MS Stephen Rodway only “reached captain after 10 years in the army“. So he served ten years, and gained promotion.
What are they supposed to have done wrong?
Nothing wrong, but they can’t win. By which I mean they’d also have been attacked if they hadn’t attended a Remembrance Day event. Simply because they’re Reform.
Jeff Jones then tells the tale of a man he knew:
Twenty years ago I was on a committee with a guy from the TECs [Training and Enterprise Councils] in Wales. Great guy. We talked about cricket.
I didn’t even know he was in the army. Years later there was his obituary in The Times. He was the guy who planned the SAS operations! As I said, they don’t say anything.
I’m sure we can all understand someone who’d been involved with special forces, or intelligence work, keeping a low profile. To begin with, they’re probably still covered by the Official Secrets Act, and perhaps a target for whichever groups or organisations they were operating against.
Is this section suggesting that those involved in clandestine operations don’t attend Remembrance Day ceremonies, while those involved in less glamorous work shouldn’t attend? Nor should cadets?
So who does Jeff Jones expect to turn up at his local war memorial on that Sunday in November – the massed pipes and drums of Antifa?
I’m sorry, Jeff, but you’ve gone off on one here and you’ve allowed your antipathy towards Reform to get the better of you. Worse, linking a public figure with fascism was dangerously irresponsible.
So why did Nation.Cymru publish it? Because it served the agenda.
◊
IT GOES ON . . .
Just when you might think anti-Reform hysteria at Nation.Cymru can’t get any worse, it’s ratcheted up by Martin Shipton himself. With a contribution bordering on the dishonest. Here it is: The new Senedd voting system is useless and pernicious.
‘Imperfect’, maybe; ‘In need of change’, perhaps; but “pernicious” is a bit OTT.
Let’s start by reminding you that I explained how we’d arrived at the new voting system back in March 2024 with, Senedd Cymru (Electoral Candidates List) Bill.
Shipton believes the new system is rubbish, even dangerous – because too many Reform MSs were elected. The rest is just dressing and personal attacks. Here’s a selection:
The fact is that the new system is a disaster. Let no one tell you otherwise.
What it has done is enable candidates with little or no affinity with, or knowledge of, the constituencies in which they stood to get elected.
Of course, Labour never parachutes unknown candidates into safe Welsh seats.
And how many Labour Members of the previous Senedd had moved to Wales, or had a tenuous connection with their constituency or region?
Arguing that Reform SMs have somehow tricked the electors, is very thin ice for Shipton to be skating on. Let’s remember Sarah Cooper-Lesadd, elected for Reform in May, and then, once the summer recess was over, switching to Plaid Cymru.
Some believe it was all planned. If true, then the girl from Townhill (as she reminds us) lied to the electors of Pen-y-bont Bro Morgannwg.
Not only did she escape censure but Nation.Cymru and other outlets gleefully reported her ‘Glad I escaped’ tales of life within Reform. The party she’d been happy to stand for just a few months earlier!
Then, in explaining what he believes to be the usual route in politics, from “grassroots community activist“, Shipton gives brief bios for each party. Here’s one:
Conservatives were typically either ambitious businesspeople, deferential working-class Tories or nerdy students.
“Deferential working-class Tories“! What’s that mean – forelock-tuggers? If so, how insulting; yet so revealing of the attitudes of middle class ‘progressives’ towards decent, ordinary people, and especially since Brexit.
As for “nerdy students“, the Conservative, and conservative, students I’ve met seem to be the most rational and balanced within that sector. They tend to think for themselves rather than just submit to the brainwashing.
The whiskery old sage concluded by attacking the same MSs as Jeff Jones had a few days earlier: Christiana Emsley, Steven Rodaway and Art Wright.
∼
Let’s be clear: a system is just a mechanism for doing something. If it can be described as “useless and pernicious” in what it delivers, then the blame lies with those who created that mechanism.
The voting system for the Senedd, used for the first time in May, was cobbled together by Labour and Plaid Cymru – yet it received little or no criticism from the likes of Shipton previously.
So what’s changed? Obviously, it was the result in May.
The system failed to deliver what it was supposed to deliver because Reform had not been factored into the machinations.
The consequence was Reform getting just 76,680 votes less than Plaid Cymru, and 228,782 votes more than Labour. Combine the percentages and Plaid + Labour = 46.5%.
◊
CONCLUSION
Obviously Reform is not everybody’s cup of tea, but no political party is. That’s why a democracy has a choice of parties. The problem in the Corruption Bay bubble is the belief that ‘choice’ should be limited to Labour and Plaid Cymru.
With Lib Dems and Greens making up the numbers if needed, while also serving to hopefully legitimise a term like ‘consensus’.
For me, and many others, that’s no choice at all. That’s the Globalist Uniparty: Fully supportive of net zero and its consequences; telling us Donald Trump is evil (so is Elon Musk); demanding we keep the borders open to all those doctors and engineers; insisting we go to war with Russia to maintain cocaine supplies to Ukraine.
While constantly warning us not to vote for a party that Shippo says, “promotes itself as a disruptive force”.
But that is exactly the point. More and people are turning to parties that promise to challenge or dismantle a system working against their household finances, the safety of their communities, and the fundamental values of Western societies.
I’ve told you about my exchange with Jeff Jones; I saw no point in contacting Martin Shipton, he’s too far gone; but I did reach out on Saturday to Emily Price, in the email you see below.
I’ve had no reply.
UPDATE: It has been pointed out to me that I missed out the ‘l’ from the email address. Have now re-sent it to correct address.
∼
Those who persuade themselves that Nigel Farage is Hitler reborn, and Reform his Brownshirts, are perfectly entitled to believe that. I’m no admirer myself, but I keep my views this side of the loony-bin gates.
The whole point of this piece can be summed up like this. If I want to buy the Daily Telegraph, then I pay to buy the paper I want to read. That’s me exercising my freedom of choice with my money.
But with Nation.Cymru we have a site that is hopelessly partisan, becoming increasingly shrill and irrational; an outlet that I and many other have no time for – but we are paying for it through ‘Welsh Government’ funding.
Nation.Cymru either becomes the news and current affairs outlet it was supposed to be, or those who agree with its rantings pay to have their prejudices confirmed through donations and subscriptions.
Either way, public funding of Nation.Cymru must stop.
♦ end ♦
© Royston Jones 2026




























































































