Child Abuse in a One-party State

Just over two years ago I published Do you know where your child is tonight? In which I explained how children are being taken into care, often in Cardiff, then moved by private companies to Swansea and other areas where property is cheaper.

This was being done with the consent or even the connivance of Labour-controlled Cardiff council and implemented by – and to the financial benefit of – persons who often enjoyed Labour Party connections.

It was even alleged that children were being taken into care unnecessarily. Often from single mothers, and others it was felt would be ignored if they complained to anyone.

At the other end of this trafficking we saw homes opening in Swansea about which Swansea council knew nothing. This inevitably meant that these establishments were often not monitored and the children in them vulnerable to many dangers.

Click to open enlarged in separate tab

As the article in WalesOnline (from which the above image is taken) put it: ‘Swansea currently has 13 homes registered with Care Inspectorate Wales (CIW), with at least four more due to open in the next year. Only one of them is a Swansea Council-registered home.’

But of course, Swansea council is also controlled by Labour.

A major player in this racket was Priority Childcare Ltd, run by Paul Anthony O’Donnell and Leonard Charles Drane. (Companies House entry.) With Priority Childcare in turn owned by another of their companies, POLD Holdings Ltd.

On March 31 last year O’Donnell and Drane bade farewell to both companies. They no doubt made a handsome profit from selling out to Orbis Education and Care Ltd.

Orbis had itself been sold in 2017 for £28m to August Equity LLP. One of a whole stable of investment vehicles under the ‘August’ label. With these ultimately controlled – apparently – by David Timothy Lonsdale and Philip Michael Rattle.

Which means that many children’s homes in southern Wales are now run by – private equity funds. A curse on anyone who dares think that making money may henceforth be the priority!

It always was. And the problem is not confined to Wales. As this report from the Guardian a few days ago makes clear.

Another report from last week telling us Swansea council is buying property for children’s homes, also says: ‘ . . . some independent children’s care providers were . . . withdrawing offers to place Welsh children because the Welsh Government wanted profit to be removed from the sector.’

Will owners of children’s homes in Wales, like Orbis Equity LLP, sell up . . . or will they bring in children from England, where the profit motive is still allowed?

If it’s the latter, what will be the status of English-owned children’s homes in Wales housing children from England? Who will register, inspect, and regulate them?

The Likely Lads. Click to open enlarged in separate tab

If the profit motive is to be removed from children’s homes then the beneficiaries could well be Labour’s cronies in the third sector.

O’Donnell and Drane being aware in advance of the intention to remove the profit motive might explain them selling Priority Childcare. But they saw a fresh opening in supplying staff, which explains why, a short time before selling out, they set up Allcare and Education Recruitment Ltd (Inc. 12 February, 2020), and Allcare and Education Recruiters Ltd (9 September, 2020).

And here’s the Allcare website.

For their first year the companies had just one director, Marc David Elsey of Trelewis, then O’Donnell and Drane showed up. Was there a reason the two did not wish to be associated with the old company and the new companies simultaneously?

Could it be because these new companies recruit staff for . . . the old company? Come to that, have they really severed all links with Priority Childcare Ltd? We know they’re no longer directors, but do they still hold shares?

Then, for some reason, the dynamic duo has a third recruitment company, Ace Recruiters Ltd, formed in September 2020. Which means that during the first year of Covid-19 lockdown, O’Donnell and Drane set up three new recruitment companies.

Cooperating with Allcare we find Noble Training Solutions. Despite the rather impressive website this company is a one-man band with, according to the accounts filed for y/e 30.04.2021, no employees.

I suspect that the sole director given for Noble Training Solutions, ‘Mr Gareth John Noble’, is in fact Dr Gareth Noble of Swansea University, though a resident of Cardiff, and a specialist in autism.

I do hope the day job doesn’t interfere too much with his money-making side-line.

A question for the local authorities of south Wales: You are taking children from their parents (often single mothers), and regularly placing them in homes some distance away – do you know who ultimately owns and runs those homes? Do you care?

What you are about to read is from the perspective of an ex-Swansea council employee who was offered 17K in return for her silence about the unethical practices of Swansea council and South Wales Police.

So take it away, Dr Gail John . . .

I was a primary teacher/special educational needs (SEN) teacher who worked for Swansea local authority for twenty years from 1994-2014. I am a fellow of the Royal Society of Public Health, a tutor of postgraduate university students at Goldsmiths London, an academic and is a member of the Bar Human Rights Committee. I stood as one of six Police and Crime Commissioner (PCC) candidates in last year’s elections as the only trauma informed candidate and attained a respectable 13K votes (attaining this without any leaflets).

My extensive advocacy work since 2012 helping and supporting vulnerable children and families right across the South Wales region opened my eyes wide to the large-scale corruption, financial abuse and exploitation that exists within Welsh public services, which some might reference as ‘legal human trafficking’.

I am currently calling for a public inquiry into South Wales Police,  based on the case documented within this book.

At the beginning at this month, March 2022, I was contacted by a distraught mother who told me of her horrific experience of how Swansea council tried to coerce her into signing a Section 47 and it is thought that this was to have her son wrongfully removed into care. This happened directly after her son disclosed child sexual abuse within a Swansea primary school.

I was absolutely appalled that the practise of ‘legal human trafficking’ is still ongoing in Swansea, that I immediately made attempts to safeguard this lady from the unethical practises of the Labour council.

Just like many others right across the region, I reference Alexis Jay (2022) and her findings regarding the failure to follow child protection procedures in the Labour run council.

I have also personally experienced the Labour council trying to financially profit through a thwarted attempt to unethically ‘legally traffick’ my own daughter into care after I exposed fraud and child abuse at the school where I was working as a Special Educational Needs Co-ordinator (SENCo) at the time.

I have evidence of Swansea councillors abusing their powers of trust when children themselves asked for financial help to pay for GCSEs. One child who contacted Councillor Jennifer Raynor in 2015, ended up becoming a target and potential victim of Swansea council’s financial exploitation as directly after Jennifer Raynor stated that the council wouldn’t waste public money on SEN children who were ‘bound to fail’ (breaching her ethical code of public office, Human Rights Act 1998 and the Equality Act 2010), this child became the subject of a child protection investigation where it emerged that there was no evidence to justify Swansea council’s decision to initiate this.

Furthermore, I had been working hard with this fourteen-year-old child to prepare her for her Sociology GCSE which the family paid over £200 for the exam at a private exam centre (I taught the child for free). This child had one exam on the Friday and the second exam on the Monday. However, after successfully sitting the exam on the Friday, the letter from Swansea social services arrived in the family home and the child never sat the second exam on the Monday. This fourteen-year-old child attained a B grade in the first exam and was on target for a high grade until Swansea council saw this child through the lens of making themselves a quick £32000 (equivalent rate 2022).

Many people across the Swansea region know that instead of following correct child protection procedures when allegations of child abuse are brought before Swansea council, the council and South Wales Police prefer making up lies, and believe they are above the law.

After receiving the information from the Swansea mother who was yet another victim of the unethical practices of Swansea council, I detailed some of the problems I have encountered in the city, with the education authority, the wider council, the police, and the local health board. This ranged from denial to intimidation to a laughable attempt to buy my silence!

Jac adds . . .

What Dr John has to say is set out in the form of a letter addressed to Councillor Robert Smith, cabinet member for Education Improvement, Learning & Skills at Swansea Council. I have withheld a number of names.

This being Swansea, and as we’re dealing with the Labour Party, I was not in the least surprised to read in Smiffy’s Register of Interests:

Son in receipt of grant from the Thomas and Elizabeth Williams Trust administered by the Council for postgraduate study (awarded 06.11.19)
Wife employed as exam invigilator occasionally in Swansea schools, on a casual basis

The Labour family that troughs together, stays together.

Now read Dr John’s letter to Councillor Smith.

Dear Mr Robert Smith, Education Councillor for Swansea,

Thank you for taking the time to talk briefly on the phone last night.

I understand that (a Swansea parent) has presented very alarming evidence, concerning bullying and systematic abuse after she disclosed the child sexual abuse of her son at a Swansea primary school. After making this disclosure, this mother was further bullied by social services (and police) who tried to trick her into signing a Section 47 to remove her son into care and implied that she was mentally ill.

I can verify that this lady is not an isolated case but it seems that bullying and scapegoating is a common practice in Swansea when it comes to covering up child abuse, medical negligence, fraud, miscarriages of justice or educational incompetence in Swansea (see Serious Child Practice Review Report submission and multiple evidence below).

The information in this email is presented in four parts:

  1. National research evidence driven from England due to the high social poverty statistics in Swansea.
  2. The reasons why I help so many people in Swansea and beyond South Wales. Evidence to back up and support (a Swansea parent). Personal experiences that are almost identical to this lady.
  3. Helping others caught as victims of abuse and victims of educational failure  in Swansea, including Serious Concise Child Practice Reviews where a child died due to medical negligence in Swansea.
  4. Trauma Informed solutions to try to bring investment to reverse the pain and poverty from the abusive practice.

1/ National research evidence driven from England due to the high social poverty statistics in Swansea.

The recent Independent Inquiry into Child Sexual Abuse IICSA (February, 2022) has also recently highlighted this systematic bullying in Swansea regarding the covering up of child abuse in the Alexis Jay 2022 report. This concurs with the voice of Swansea participants who were involved in my six-year education doctorate about adverse childhood experiences and their impact upon educational failure (published by University of Sheffield 2019).

You will see all the social poverty statistics about Swansea in this thesis.

To briefly summarise, I focused on educational failure and this is what I found out –

Participant 6 – was targeted/terrified by Swansea social services and police after her mother raised child abuse concerns concerning both an educational professional and a church member.

Participant 7 – was raped in foster care aged 9. This was covered up by Swansea education and social services. Instead of being safeguarded, the victim was victim-blamed and received psychiatric diagnosis of ADHD (against CSA specialist advice as her symptoms were because of the abuse she suffered) and drugged with Ritalin.

Participant 8 – sexually assaulted in school, school did not follow child protection policy, got child to shake hands with her abuser.

Participant 9 – was raped, no safeguarding procedures followed, instead he was sectioned aged nineteen and diagnosed with schizophrenia put on multiple drugs. Financially exploited and abused under social services care.

Participant 10 – talked about being attacked in her dormitory in a Swansea university, South Wales Police lied to her to cover it up and make her drop the case. The victim was made to drop out of university while the perpetrator was protected.

Participant 11 – sexually abused at school and home, ended up sexually exploited aged 14 by gangs and prostituted out to men three times her age when she was living under Swansea children’s services. When she brought gang rape allegations to South Wales Police, they laughed at her and one officer ‘tried it on with her’. Instead of following safeguarding procedures, she was given psychiatric diagnosis of ADHD and given strong drugs. Her child was removed from her with her own child abuse used as evidence against her.

2/  The reasons why I help so many people in Swansea and beyond South Wales. Evidence to back up and support (redacted name to protect identity). Personal experiences that are almost identical to this lady.

My background

I worked as a primary teacher for nearly twenty years employed by Swansea council from 1994-2013/2014. During this time, I worked extremely hard, obtained promotions in the three schools I taught at, contributed to four successful inspections, along with working exceptionally hard to self-fund my multiple postgraduate qualifications to improve outcomes for all my students. My postgraduate qualifications included a Doctorate in Education (2012-2019), Master’s Degree in Education (1994-1998), British Dyslexia QTS qualified teacher status and postgraduate certificate in Special Learning Difficulties or Dyslexia (SpLD) (1996-1997), Graduate Diploma in Special educational Needs (GradDipSEN) – Qualified Special Education Needs Coordinator (SENCO) status (2009-2011), Teaching English as a Foreign Language (TEFL) (2014).

In October 2012, my outstanding educational results for all children (especially the SEN children under my care and leadership) especially the SEN children in Pontybrenin (a Gorseinon school) were recognised by the University of Sheffield who nominated me to speak at largest teacher conference in the UK and I was invited to be a speaker at this conference (January 2013).

I worked at Pontybrenin Primary from October 2000 and was promoted to SENCO at Pontybrenin Primary by (a former head teacher) and started this position in January 2009. Education councillor Will Evans was a governor at the school during this time period. (Jac: Labour councillor Evans is a former senior police officer.)

Acting headteacher Matthew O’Brien joined the school January 2009, the same time I started this position of SENCO, and he informed everyone that the SEN children had failed under the provision of SENCO A. B. Next, Matthew O’Brien informed everyone that the school needed to be put into Special Measures in order to access a substantial amount of government money which was to be spent on the SEN children.

Strangely enough, after being informed that the SEN children and provision had failed under A. B. (January 2009), A B was given a glowing reference and received a promotion to deputy headteacher at Tre-Uchaf (Easter 2009) and was made an ESTYN inspector. (A. B. is now also running her own therapy outfit in Llandeilo.)

In March 2009, it also emerged that a staff member was summoned to attend court and admitted three counts of fraud which took place years before in 2007 over a long time-period. She had not disclosed her crime to headteacher at the time of her crime, Alison Jenkins. Alison Jenkins was bullied out of her job and left December 2008, after being targeted (like some of the other staff, myself included) with malicious anonymous letters.

The barrage of malicious anonymous letters were written about staff members including myself from the end of July 2008-December 2008 and suddenly stopped after the Headteacher Alison Jenkins handed in her resignation. Alison Jenkins was an excellent headteacher and a lady with integrity who safeguarded children and staff first.

According to governor, M. C., one of the last malicious letters that went to the police from office staff, B. J., attacked and denigrating my character for receiving a promotion in the school under Alison Jenkins and also viciously attacking Alison Jenkins for demoting (perpetrator of fraud) for having a poor attendance. Just two months after the last of these nasty letters stopped, (perpetrator’s) fraud came into the public domain where she admitted three counts of fraud (March 2009). Alison Jenkins who had left the school at this point, knew nothing about the crime until she saw it/read it on the news.

Acting headteacher Matthew O’Brien (January 2009-April 2009) did not follow correct safeguarding regulations in reporting (perpetrator) to the GTCW, instead she was given a glowing reference and so obtained another teaching job. During a similar time-frame, malicious letters also emerged in ex-Pontybrenin headteacher David Greenaway’s church where it emerged that similar scapegoating practices of covering over abuse where pastor protected an adult male sexual predator who sent explicit pictures of himself to a vulnerable young person.

Instead of the pastor reporting this crime to the police, he hid it and gave this perpetrator a glowing reference, sent him to Bible College, and then gave him a job back in his church.

Pastor Michael Williams of Elim City Church, Swansea, enjoying a buffet with Liberty Church / Bible College safeguarding officer Hugh Griffiths who did not follow child protection procedures regarding Charmain Speirs. Click to open enlarged in separate tab

As SENCO at Pontybrenin school, I can verify that none of the Special Measures’ additional money was ever spent on the Special Educational Needs children. I also examined the SEN results which were deemed as failing under A. B. and used as a reason to put the school into special measures to acquire money for the SEN children. However, there was no failure and the money was never spent on the SEN children. It was all a farce, and fraudulent activity.

Instead of the SEN children having the money spent on them, under Phil Williams, the school had major construction work, walls and partitions and outdoor provisions. When I met Alison Jenkins, neither of us could understand where all the money had come from and how the school all of a sudden had gone from a school struggling to a school that had money to lavish on new carpets, desks, etc. However, when money is obtained for SEN children under the guise of special measures and not spent on SEN children – this amounts to FRAUD.

Moreover, when Phil Williams was asked awkward questions about where the money had come from to pay for the building work, new desks, etc – he began to display bullying types of behaviour especially to SEN children and those asking these questions. In May 2012 he came into my class to observe one of my lessons on a Monday (it emerged he had deliberately hit a SEN child over the head with a book on the previous Friday). Phil Williams stated it was an unsatisfactory lesson and his reason was because I had used peer tutoring. However, peer tutoring was a teaching and learning strategy recommended by the Welsh Government. The University of Sheffield submitted my excellent results from this time period in 2012, where I was asked to speak at an educational conference about the power of peer tutoring (January 2013),

At this time, at least three female staff members were forced to go to their unions about the bullying behaviour of Phil Williams.

In March 2013, as SENCO of Pontybrenin Primary School, I raised serious concerns about the abusive behaviour of headteacher Phil Williams towards the SEN children to Swansea Local Authority head of inclusion Robin Brown / Lesley Evans and the Education Minister Leighton Andrews, who resigned a few months later.

In March/April 2013, Phil Williams was put in charge of his own child abuse investigation about himself in his own organisation backed by safeguarding officer Paul Henwood and chair of governors Jeffrey Lewis. This was against all child protection laws.

In September/October 2013 – six months after I raised the concerns – Pontybrenin school and Swansea council abused their positions of trust and to cover up child abuse. They used unethical Swansea social services (E.R.) and police friend of Phil Williams – Jonathan Bainbridge – to abuse their positions of trust to try to bully me into silence. The police abused their positions to intimidate my friend Charmain Speirs (who was murdered just 18 months later) and made fun of her SEN (family member name redacted to protect identity) who the police described as a child with demons (evidenced by Jonathan Bainbridge’s document).

Inept social worker E.R. accidentally left a nasty anonymous malicious letter and police friend of the headteacher, Jonathan Bainbridge’s police document which contained 8 out of 10 breaches of police professional standards. Headteacher Phil Williams had given his police friend Jonathan Bainbridge’s wife Lisa Bainbridge a job in Pontybrenin school with no interview or qualifications.

I asked my very well qualified colleagues (social workers / police) at the University of Sheffield who told me that these professionals had broken the law. Therefore, I removed consent and disengaged from Swansea inept professionals in order to safeguard my family from the abuse which is rife in Swansea council.

April 1st 2014 – I resigned from my teaching position as I could not work for a council that allows abuse towards (SEN) children.

April 2nd 2014 – I was offered £17,000 by Pontybrenin School / Swansea council to keep my mouth shut but I would have had to sign a gagging order which I did not do. I did not receive their silencing money.

Click to enlarge in separate tab

June 2014 – Head of Inclusion Robin Brown makes threats to me – he told me to destroy all my evidence of Swansea’s abuse or he would report me to GTCW. I spoke to GTCW and found out Robin Brown was just trying to bully me as I was told I had not done anything wrong. Instead I found out that I could report Phil Williams and multiple professionals for their part in abusive practice towards SEN children. GTCW did nothing about any of the unethical abusive practice. They chose to ignore the abuse towards the SEN children, and the only thing they did was publish the fact that Swansea teacher Ellen Lloyd’s fraud in 2007 came to their knowledge 7 years later and was not even reported accurately.

In 2016, I was requested to go to police professional standards after ESTYN reported TWO MALE Police for unethical practices towards Charmain Speirs who was murdered in bizarre circumstances just 18 months after police abused their positions of trust in going to her house under false pretences as part of their retaliation towards me. The police did not follow procedures, the IPCC upheld the complaint while South Wales police scapegoated TWO FEMALE police officers who had never even been part of the complaint in the first place.

In 2018, Leighton Andrews (Education Minister in 2013) apologised after I contacted him to offer him support when he was being bullied after Carl Sargeant committed suicide. He apologised that proper child protection procedures were not followed in 2013 and stated that lessons had been learned. However, this is just a phrase that is used as a sticking plaster and the truth is that NO LESSONS HAVE BEEN LEARNED.


3/ Helping others caught as victims of abuse and victims of educational failure in Swansea, including Serious Concise Child Practice Reviews where I have included a report where a child died as a result of medical negligence in Swansea.

I’ve been involved in helping multiple people who have been targeted and abused throughout the city. I was requested to appear as an expert witness in court by a judge and have helped lots of people acquire qualifications after they were failed at school, including tutoring master degree students. I conducted an in-depth doctoral research study (2012-2019) about Adverse Childhood Experiences in Swansea and found that systematic abuse is a common occurrence. Alexis Jay Report February 2022 found similar findings.

Last year I was involved in two Serious Concise Child Practice Reviews where two children died because of professional negligence. One report is attached (link above). I helped the man in the report (he’s given consent for you to see the report) move into a house after his daughter had died and he was bullied by social services and police. He was deliberately made homeless by social services. This was after his daughter had died due to medical negligence. The bullying towards him was relentless.

4/ Trauma Informed solutions to try to bring investment to reverse the pain and poverty from the abusive practice

Just recently I had a meeting with head of housing Steve Porter, 2/2/22, where I have acquired PDNES who are linked to multi-million pound investors willing to bring investment and regeneration to Swansea. PDNES are an award winning trauma informed supportive housing organisation who specialise in CSA, trauma and recovery using a person-centred approach. There is nothing like this in Wales. Steve Porter recognised that Swansea like other councils in Wales have a need and asked PDNES to write out their model in order to write letters of intent and demand to give to PDNES so they could give these to the investors in order to bring regeneration to Swansea to reverse poverty statistics. We are still waiting.

Unfortunately, it appears that Swansea Council is still denying that they have a problem.

However, in recent weeks. journalists from ITV (Dean), Sky News (Owen) and the BBC (Gavin) have made contact through Adele Rose-Morgan who sits on many of your boards along with Jason Lovell Plaid Cymru wanting to meet Adam Price of Plaid Cymru; and Wayne Erasmus, of Gwlad, wanting to investigate the revelations about the scandal of the abuse towards SEN families in Swansea ABMU/Swansea Bay and the Child Sexual Abuse IICSA (2022) report.

I hope with the elections coming up, it will motivate the council to see the need to start properly protecting children and young people in Swansea.

I am trying my best to bring solutions to Swansea through bringing high quality trauma informed supportive housing provision to our city linked to award-winning Gary Crooks and Nevres Kemal (social worker and Baby P whistle-blower) who Steve Porter head of housing had the privilege of meeting with me last month. The consequences of failed provision and underperformance under Will Evans, Rob Stewart and others’ leadership in Swansea council has resulted in high social poverty, homelessness, etc and this is not a good investment of tax payers’ money!

Unfortunately, Swansea council appear to be ignoring the problem and continuing to turn a blind eye to all the published research and their own statistics. However, turning a blind eye is not effective child protection. This is incompetence. Those who can do, do; those who can’t do their jobs bully others to cover-up for their own incompetence.

I will be keeping a close eye on safeguarding (name redacted to protect identity), as I know that previous systematic abuse, bullying and retaliation from Swansea council has brought much anxiety to this lady. Bullying towards SEN children and women by men and women in professional positions of power in Swansea council IS ABUSE and should be challenged. There needs to be accountability because NO ONE IS ABOVE THE LAW. OUR SOCIAL POVERTY STATISTICS ARE CRYING OUT FOR JUSTICE!


I look forward to your swift response.

Kindest regards
Dr Gail John


Childcare in Wales is degenerating from a bit of a mess into a national scandal. Children are being taken into care at almost double the rate for England.

The stark figures. Click to open enlarged in separate tab

The reasons for this are complex, but most can be traced back to the problem of one political party exercising too much control, for too long. Not just in the political sphere, but also in the fields of health and education.

That, coupled with no effective political opposition, and no media worthy of the name.

Though one fascinating feature, cropping up again and again, is the linkage between the Labour Party and evangelical churches. (Perhaps we might add the police.) Even the husband of Charmain Speirs, who died in strange circumstances in Kenya (and who Dr John met when Speirs spent time in Swansea), is ‘a pastor with the Global Light Revival Ministries’.

Another example of what I’m talking about would be the Jonathan Norbury case. Norbury, a teacher at Pontarddulais School, seems to have escaped jail by persuading jurors that the schoolgirls he was having sex with were over 16.

When the allegations first came to light Swansea Council allowed Norbury to write his own reference – and then gave him £8,000. For what?

I mention Norbury because in addition to being a teacher he was a deacon, and a ‘youth pastor’, at an evangelical church. (No, I am not making this up.)

Then there’s Robin Brown, Head of Inclusion at Swansea council, who Dr John mentioned in her letter. I’m told he belongs to the Lifepoint Church.

It is suggested that the link between the Swansea Labour Party and these Evangelical churches may be provided by Freemasonry.

In my introduction I suggested that if the ‘Welsh Government’ intends removing the profit motive from child care then the beneficiaries could be third sector groups. I suppose we shouldn’t rule out certain favoured churches.

However our tribunes may try to explain it, the fact is that Wales has a shameful record for taking children into care. ‘Shameful’, because in many cases it’s being done for the wrong reasons. And in other cases, for no reason at all.

This BBC report from last June tells us that the percentage of children being taken into care has almost doubled in less than twenty years. But only in Wales. Which is why it cannot be divorced from devolution.

‘Wales now has the highest proportion of children in the UK being cared for by the state, prompting one expert to raise concerns.

There are 7,170 (latest: 7,265) children being looked after away from home in Wales – which is 1.14% of children. The current UK average is 0.72% of children.’

While the Wales Centre for Public Policy in its report, Children’s social services and care rates in Wales: A survey of the sector, confirms the problem.

Click to open enlarged in separate tab

As I say, something is very wrong here, and the problem is getting worse.

Given the cross-border operations of the third sector, housing associations, and others there must be the possibility that the figures for Wales are skewed by children being brought in from England.

If so, then this must stop.

Though if that is not the answer then we need to explain the glaring differences in the percentages for children taken into care in Wales and those taken into care in the other administrations of these islands.

We also need to analyse the differences within Wales. By and large these differences are between urban areas, which generally have higher percentages, and rural areas, with lower percentages. In other words, areas controlled by the Labour Party and areas run by other political parties, or coalitions, or ‘Independents’.

Click to open enlarged in separate tab

Though the tragic tale reported (above) in last Wednesday’s Daily Post might suggest that the system isn’t too good in rural areas either, and that children who perhaps should be in care are being ignored.

And who could forget the poor boy in rural Ceredigion who died of scurvy.

Whatever the fuller picture, the situation in Wales has worsened under devolution and 23 years of Labour Party domination. Which means that either children are being taken into care unnecessarily, or else Wales has become materially poorer under devolution and one result is more children being taken into care.

Neither possibility reflects well on the Labour Party / ‘Welsh Government’.

Click to open enlarged in separate tab

Things could be about to get worse. For since March 21 it is unlawful to administer physical punishment to a child. Which means that good parents having a momentary lapse risk having their children taken from them.

To be placed in homes that are badly regulated, often not known to the local authority where they are located, and owned by City of London investors.

Forget the propaganda and the gestures from Corruption Bay about saving the planet, welcoming refugees, etc., etc, what you’ve read here is the reality of modern Wales for too many of our people.

As an example of gesture politics, we have a Children’s Commissioner who seems more concerned with obeying the quasi-Marxist demands of Black Lives Matter than with looking after our kids.

Priorities, eh!

Click to open enlarged in separate tab

Wales needs the kind of fundamental change that is impossible while the dead hand of the Labour Party allows its vampiric cronies to prey on us.

At the very least, we are entitled to a statement from the so-called ‘Welsh Government’ giving us their explanation for why an ever-increasing number of Welsh children are being taken into care.

♦ end


© Royston Jones 2022

Notify of

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

Miles off topic but relating to the Misrule by Cardiff Bay cliques, I see that those 4 Aelodau Senedd found drinking on the premises during a strict curfew have been let off. Bit rich that, when the majority of members of the Senedd have been rightly critical of the antics of No.10 Downing St.

Maybe we have moved on from “one rule for all” to one rule for the select elevated crachach and another for the scum out in the communities. And it’s O.K for us righteous wokey tossers in the Bay to guzzle wine but those awful overlords in London ought to be flogged for behaving in a similar manner.

Red Flag

Newport Wafer Fab, the UK’s largest semiconductor plant, is to be sold to Nexperia, a Dutch subsidiary of the Chinese technology company Wingtech.

Gail John

Regarding the church leader who also is a teacher at Cardiff University who failed to follow child protection policy to protect Charmain Speirs (who just happened to be murdered 18 months after being targeted by bent police who had a conflict of interest and broke 8 out of 10 of their police professional standards in September 2013). Charmain told these police of her suspicions of a pedophile ring and this was covered up by the safeguarding officer and the South Wales Police.

I find it quite interesting that South Wales Chief of Police Peter Vaughan at that time, received his honorary doctorate just months later in 2014 FROM CARDIFF UNIVERSITY.

TWO KEY people directly involved in the systematic cover-up of the Clydach Murders (one worked in Cockett Police Station and the other was involved in destroying the evidence) were connected to Pontybrenin Primary School. This is the same school involved in the systematic covering over of fraud and abuse towards children, along with Swansea council and South Wales Police, who together engaging in deliberate scapegoating and fabricating evidence to set-up innocent people – mirroring what they did to David Morris.

Dai Morris died in prison an innocent man who paid for the crimes of others (evidenced by the official court documents). WE NEED A PUBLIC INQUIRY INTO SOUTH WALES POLICE who write lies about people and fabricate a false narrative on their police documents to harm innocent people, including removing children wrongfully into care. The Justice Commission in Wales Report (2019) urged Welsh local authorities to take preventative measures to keep families together.

The statistics speak for themselves, as number of children in looked after care (LAC) in 2021 in Wales was 115 per 10,000 compared to 67 per 10,000 LAC children in England. Looked after children in Wales has risen from 89 per 10,000 children in 2015 to 115 per 10,000 children in 2021. Tax payers need to start challenging this nepotism and cronyism which is dangerously rife in Swansea (evidenced by the Swansea’s social poverty statistics).

We need to rise up and challenge the systematic abuse that empowers this abusive narcissistic group of people who have put themselves in the position of GOD to decide whose lives do not matter defining them as ‘throwaway’ , while the elite liars, abusers and criminals are getting promotions and jobs for their wives and family members all paid for by tax payers money under Swansea’s Labour council.

I had a reply from Robert Smith, who has said that he’s not in a position to do anything about ALL the evidence of the fraud and illegal activities that was sent to him. Robert Smith is a nice person and a decent guy but if he challenges the illegal activities in Swansea council, he runs the risk of becoming a target himself.

Gail John

Jac, I do believe your connection between dodgy church leaders and the Freemason brother/sisterhood is quite accurate in Swansea. One of the key people (mentioned above) who was directly connected to the systematic covering up of the Clydach Murders, just happened to have a prominent job at Cockett Police Station and went to Elim Church Swansea. I have always wondered who was responsible at Cockett Police Station for spending hours and hours and hours of their time destroying, editing and deleting all the damning evidence connected to the real criminals found on the Police Holmes Documentation. This deliberate corruption and criminal activity of South Wales Police relating to the Holmes Computer Documentation was uncovered by Brian Thornton (2014) of Winchester University’s Truth Project. South Wales Police are yet to answer / disclose who was responsible deliberately altering official documentation and destroying key evidence in this murder investigation. This unethical activity gave their police officers an unfair advantage while they were under investigation themselves. This is a direct breach of Police Professional Standards 6 – Duties and Responsibilities and Police Professional Standards 9 – Conduct – conspiracy to prevent the course of justice. So why didn’t South Wales Police report this to the UK Independent Professional Standards (IPCC/IOPC) in accordance with their police policies and public duties? Why hasn’t anyone been brought to book for their role the systematic covering up of the Clydach Murders – when the evidence of corruption is overwhelming? No wonder South Wales Police think they can get away with fabricating evidence on their police documents to stitch innocent people up and remove children wrongfully into care . Their behaviour shows they think they are above the law and they blatantly have no respect for the IOPC and their police professional standards. I am standing against the Leader of Swansea Council in the elections (MORRISTON), as an independent candidate, in an attempt to try to clean up the nepotism and corruption that is currently rife right across the Swansea region.


Chuckled at your reference to Jamie George in your tweet column. The Saracens and England hooker might turn out to be an Ultra Brit but I am assured by others who have spent time working with him that he has no signs of confusion about his identity and has no form for running away from the scenes of motor accidents and later resorts to cries of “rape” as part of his tissue of lame excuses. I met Jamie Wallis on the doorstep when he was pitching for the job and at that time he gave the impression that he was straight, although there were already rumours doing the rounds that his business track record was a touch bent. Good Tory boy material. And to his credit and that of his supporters he rid Bridgend of a Labour twat who would have given us another 5 years of grief, moaning and posturing.


Beyond good parents momentarily losing their rag, I’d include as good parents those who do physically chastise their children with the odd smacked bum or clip round the ear in a deliberate manner. As usual the meddlers have abandoned all notion of degree and kind, and conflated discipline with child abuse.

Matthew Thomas

Exactly, the same people than have banned smacking, preside over the most corrupt and harmful child social services system in the UK.

Probably so they can give themselves even more excuses to take kids into care, presumably so they can profit from it in some way.


More grist to the mill for the BritYoons and self-loathers, and their belief we’re better off being ruled by our larger neighbour, or at least the most hubristic and privileged section of its society. Of course the implication of these sorts of stances, when scratching beneath the surface of us being ‘Better Together’ or ‘One Nation’ or [Insert stock invocation of ‘The War’ here] is that us Taffies are too thick to tend to our own affairs. However, the actions of the WG does somewhat prove that point.


I remind people that devolution is at the end of the day a Brit State project. Also, Labour are a unionist party. Two facts that are pretty much a given, but I’d bet any number out there are too thick to grasp them.

Gail John

There is a difference between parental discipline and a 50 year old bully who goes out of his way to terrify and deliberately harm little SEN children. A 50 year old man who enjoys seeing the affect of his intimidation and getting a kick out of seeing SEN kids traumatised – that’s not discipline, it’s abuse. I saw a little 5 year old with multiple complex medical issues shaking so much that I thought she was having an epileptic fit. This little 5 year old girl had been born premature and even though she was aged 5, she was wearing clothes for a two year old child. She had already been through a lot in her short life having had previous heart operations, was visually impaired and had speech and language difficulties. The headteacher s relentless shouting towards this little girl in assembly just because she was crying, afraid and could not focus because her eye patch had been removed, that is not discipline. Another autistic child had his teeth smashed in by his peers after this headteacher made him a target in one of his assemblies, as he stared at this autistic child telling him that silly haircuts were not allowed in his school. This headteacher encouraged the whole school to laugh at this child and publicly humiliate him – that’s not discipline. Swansea LA and South Wales Police chose to protect this abuser. They didn’t follow correct safeguarding policies and put this abuser in charge of his own investigations on himself. Yet other parents have had their kids removed into care for less. There is evidence to show that Swansea social services remove kids into care from innocent parents with fabricated evidence from anonymous sources. This clearly isn’t a discipline or abuse debate. The same measuring stick of the law should apply to all.

David Smith

Those harrowing accounts reinforce my point about degree and kind, and obviously horrors like that have always merited punishment with the full force of the law. It’s not hard to envisage the ‘smacking ban’ perpetrating more of these horrors in the vein you describe of beefed up/fabricated accounts of the actions of loving parents.

Ellie Wales

I’m speechless. I was a SEN teacher in S Wales many years ago, with appropriate extra degree qualifications, and there were rarely any children in care.Yes, some came from very difficult home circumstances but could always find support in school.
One other point; given the drive for Welsh language education how on earth could already traumatised children from England cope? Human rights comes to mind here. These children desperately need an advocate.


No doubt Wales being, perhaps barring NI, the poorest of the ‘home nations’ is a factor at play as well?

David Smith

You’re not wrong, and your point dovetails with my other one about the smacking ban. However it is of course undeniably true that ‘feckless’ women are the scourge of the right too. We can all easily envisage single mothers on benefits getting the dander up of your archetypal Daily Mail reader!

Another factor in NI regarding less children in care per capita may be a widespread distrust of these kinds of systems with abuse scandals over the years, but that’s just speculation on my part. The Six Counties being so recently war torn you’d think would result in all sorts of bad emotional legacy and the resultant generational cycles of broken homes, substance abuse and the like. You’d expect it to be the worst of the ‘home nations’ in this regard.

Gail John

I went to the Child Commissioner’s office (just after I whistle-blew when proper child protection policies were not followed by Swansea council). The Child Commissioner’s office took the child’s name & DOB of the child who had been hit by the headteacher, but instead the Child Commissioner’s office carried out investigations on a different child (I believe the brother who I had never even taught). There is no accountability or safety for children in Wales, especially for SEN children and systematic abusive practice is rife.


The CC office is and was well aware of child protection failures in Swansea, it’s based there and it has let down an awful lot of children, not least Aaron Gilbert. Not a peep over 20 years? A Christmas tree decoration, just there for show.


As VH says it’s depressing, should be shocking but really it’s becoming par for the course. Shitty elected representatives who are rapidly absorbed into “the established way of doing things” don’t rock any boats put up with all kinds of deviance so that their miserable careers can progress. And our media talk about Putin and his corrupt regime. We have our own variation on the theme here in Wales and doing just fine for those who are party to it.

Ellie Wales

Unfortunately this ‘religious’ abuse goes hand in hand with other churches, notably the RC where abusive priests convinced children they were doing ‘God’s work’.


Just a personal theory about abuse in religious bodies be they churches, mosques or temples. Religion relies on parents bringing their kids to events, sometimes the kids are left by the parents at events while they go off to do other things. This is the kind of situation that appeals to the predatory perv who is looking out for scope to contact kids when parents are absent for an hour or more. Once they secure that contact they are able to groom and develop the “prospect”. Not surprising therefore to find pervs turning up among clergy and lay ranks. They are not created by religion, just exploit the opportunity, like what happened in the much publicised football coaching scandal of a few years ago. When those who should be vigilant fail to observe, or fail to enforce discipline, the cancer of corruption soon gets a grip in any situation.

Matthew Thomas

It’s not that surprising unfortunately. Here’s a good article that talks about how Welsh Protestant Nonconformism informs Wales’s political culture.

“aspects of Nonconformist culture have arguably played a central role in Welsh national culture since the mid-19th century. Moreover, they have fed into Welsh political life, thanks to Nonconformism’s central role in the Liberal Party, and later, Labourism. Both these traditions’ deep relationship with Nonconformism helps to explain how its culture of cronyism, conformism and an aversion to criticism has been carried into the contemporary Welsh political and cultural establishment.”


“Nonconformism helping to explain a culture of conformism”… bit odd that. Surely also labour movements around the world took at least some inspiration from the godlessness of communism?

Matthew Thomas

You should read the article, it’s pretty good. It makes sense that without an established hierarchy within the church, advancement fell back to nepotism and cronyism.


There is a statewide established hierarchy within the UK that goes right to the top, AKA the class system, and nepotism and cronyism are its bread and butter with all the old school tie bollocks and how it churns out successive generations of Etonian toffs to rise to the top.

Red Flag

It’s actually Oxford graduates that have a strangle hold on the post of PM, not old Etonians.

I think it’s only two of the PMs in the last t150 years never went to Oxford.

David Robins

Marxism is the opiate of the Marxists, deviation from the party line the new brand of heresy.


Personality cults around ‘revolutionary’ leaders are as hagiographic as it gets. Funny how ‘opposites’ end up having so much in common.


This is such a depressing missive. But thank you. I am incredibly glad that I do not have children.