The decision was handed down three days later. Anne Greagsby has now been ‘excluded’ from Plaid Cymru for twelve months. The panel consisted of Gwerfyl Jones (chair), Si\u00e2n Thomas (Carmarthen), Alun Cox (Rhondda).<\/p>\n
I can’t say I know Anne Greagsby, I’ve met her just once, in a Bala cafe after the 2015 Tryweryn commemoration. She seemed a sensible woman with her heart, and head, in the right place. And she was in good company, which I’m old-fashioned enough to believe is a useful indicator of a person’s character.<\/p>\n We follow each other on social media and that’s about the extent of any connection or relationship between me and Anne Greagsby.<\/p>\n I would have liked to have provided a link to a news report of the panel’s decision, but I could find none. Type ‘Anne Greagsby’ into the BBC website and the most recent mention is from October 2008<\/a>. There is nothing whatsoever on the ITV website. Using Google I did find a pressreader reference to the case in the Western Mail<\/em>, but when I clicked on it I was greeted with a 404 message – the story was unavailable. Fortunately I scanned the story that appeared in the Mule<\/em> and you can read it here<\/a>.<\/p>\n Other than that, all I can offer is\u00a0this from Mumsnet,<\/a> written after the decision but apparently ignorant of the outcome.\u00a0The only coverage I can find of the panel’s decision comes from the Penarth Daily News<\/a><\/em>. And then there’s this letter from today’s Western Mail<\/em>.<\/p>\n Anne Greagsby and I have friends in common, and we also share critics, among them Martyn Shrewsbury, who was mentioned in last week’s Carmarthenshire Herald, w<\/em>here ‘Cadno’ considered the Plaid Cymru leadership election<\/a>. And wrote:<\/p>\n “At this point Cadno would like to introduce you to Martyn Shrewsbury. A former leader of the Green Party in Wales, a convicted fraudster, Jungian psychotherapist, and enthusiastic user of fake media accounts, and publisher of a fascinating blog called ‘All too human<\/a>‘.<\/em><\/strong><\/span><\/p>\n Martyn Shrewsbury claims on his website for his psychotherapy business ‘He is laid back, relaxed and non-judgemental. Nothing shocks him and he is able to work with people from all backgrounds and identities’.<\/em><\/strong><\/span><\/p>\n To which Cadno can say, readers, have a gander at his blog and judge for yourself. To Cadno it appears to be the random and occasionally nonsensical ramblings of someone deep into the port after midnight and who has so many chips on their shoulders that they most probably have shares in Albert Bartlett’s Rooster Potatoes.<\/em><\/strong><\/span><\/p>\n Martyn Shrewsbury is a member of Momentum and a member of the Labour Party.<\/em><\/strong><\/span><\/p>\n He backs Leanne Wood.<\/em><\/strong><\/span><\/p>\n There’s your problem right there. Labour and Green activist backs leader of a party he opposes and which he opposes whether or not Ms Wood is the leader.<\/em><\/strong><\/span><\/p>\n Mr Shrewsbury is an archetypal Leanne Wood booster. People who don’t and won’t vote Plaid support Leanne Wood to be the leader of a party whose membership, policies, and history they hold in contempt.<\/em><\/strong><\/span><\/p>\n If you were as cracked a conspiracy theorist as Martyn Shrewsbury appears – and it seems he has been chatting with other cracked conspiracy theorists in Carmarthenshire – you might even wonder whether his support for Leanne Wood was some sort of black propaganda of the sort used by the SOE in the Second World War: a pretence at supporting Ms Wood in order to repel possible real voters for her.<\/em><\/strong><\/span><\/p>\n With friends like these, readers, Leanne Wood does not lack for enemies.”<\/em><\/strong><\/span><\/p>\n The reason I’ve quoted ‘Cadno’ is because Martyn Shrewsbury has attacked Anne Greagsby many times. He also attacks me regularly on his blog. He supported Leanne Wood and others you are about to meet, people in unofficial cross-party campaigns on niche issues that badly damaged Plaid Cymru, and contributed to Leanne Woods’ humiliation in last week’s leadership election.<\/p>\n Shrewsbury is an example of the bullies and trolls condemned in this article from today’s Times<\/em><\/a>.<\/p>\n For we are entering the bizarre world of genitocentric politics and Scrabble dream answer acronyms, where you become transphobic for refusing to accept that ‘Felicity’, that big bearded bloke in a frock, scratching his balls, is a woman.<\/p>\n In some ways, I suppose, the persecution of Anne Greagsby may be viewed as the final writhings of the niche and nasty politics introduced into Plaid Cymru by Leanne Wood, which in turn attracted the unbalanced and the obsessive to the point where this vociferous, bullying element was able to dominate a party to which it has little or no commitment.<\/p>\n For the truth was exposed last Friday morning. The heavy defeat suffered by Leanne Wood was also a rejection of the intolerance goose-stepping behind the ‘progressive’ banner. And the defeat would have been even heavier were it not for those who have left the party or been expelled since Leanne Wood and her acolytes took hold.<\/p>\n \u25ca<\/strong><\/span><\/p>\n Y MAB DAROGAN?<\/p>\n But surely, things will get better with the election of Adam Price<\/a>.<\/p>\n Adam Price is gay, and that’s not an issue for anyone except a diminishing minority of right wing bigots and religious fanatics. So can Plaid Cymru members and supporters hope that Adam Price will reclaim Plaid Cymru for Wales, and focus on those issues that matter to most people?<\/p>\n Well, maybe, maybe not.<\/p>\n Take this article from the Plaid Cymru website<\/a>, headed, ‘”Wales can not be free until our LGBT citizens are free’ says Adam Price.” <\/em>I accept that Adam Price probably didn’t write the headline, so let’s read the article in order to learn what he did say.<\/p>\n What we find is, “There has been a significant\u00a0rise in transphobia and smear campaigns directed towards the trans community in the media. Trans women in Wales in particular face significant challenges including increased vulnerability to hate crime, violence and abuse.”<\/em><\/p>\n I suppose it all hinges on what Adam Price means by “trans women”<\/em>. If he means men who have undergone the surgery to physically resemble women then I’m sure most people would agree that these should not be anyone’s targets. But if he’s referring to people like ‘Felicity’, so-called ‘chicks with dicks’, then he can expect opposition.<\/p>\n Because I agree with Anne Greagsby that a man in possession of male genitalia cannot ever, and must never<\/em>, be regarded as a woman except in the most superficial way.<\/p>\n But Adam Price also talked of ‘freedom’, that most emotive of words. At a rally protesting against some obscure piece of local government legislation he said, “I do not believe that Wales can ever truly be free until our LGBT citizens are also free.”\u00a0<\/em><\/p>\n The only way I can interpret that is that Adam Price believes the LGBT citizens of Wales or the UK are unfree. Are there gay people in prison simply for being gay? Are there discriminatory laws against gay people on the statute book?<\/p>\n Freedom is a very big word, and to misuse it in such a context is disgraceful. For it trivialises and debases genuine oppression and lack of freedom.<\/p>\n If Adam Price meant to say, ‘We haven’t yet got everything we want’,<\/em> then he should have said that, but this is not an issue about freedom, or the lack of it. And it has no impact whatsoever on whether or not Wales becomes independent.<\/p>\n In the same speech Adam Price also said, “I am proud of Plaid Cymru\u2019s record in championing LGBT rights and will continue to represent the LGBT community in Wales and campaign for\u00a0education and tolerance. Mine and Plaid Cymru\u2019s vision is of a Wales free from homophobia, biphobia and transphobia.”<\/em><\/p>\n ‘Transphobia’ of course is what Anne Greagsby was accused of. So does Plaid Cymru’s new leader support the extremists who have persecuted Anne Greagsby and so many others?<\/p>\n \u25ca<\/strong><\/span><\/p>\n THE NETWORK<\/p>\n Over the years I’ve commented on the connections between Plaid Cymru and the English Labour Party in Wales. These linkages go beyond activists in two socialist parties moaning about the Tories, they extend into the social and other spheres.<\/p>\n The Deryn connection would be one example, in which a lobbying group containing former activists of both Labour and Plaid Cymru seem to enjoy better access to certain AMs than any of those these tribunes are supposed to represent.<\/p>\n It was Deryn that persuaded Plaid Cymru to take the self-damaging step of expelling Neil McEvoy AM. One day – if Labour suffers a fit of openness – we might know how deeply involved Deryn was with the sacking (and subsequent suicide) of Labour minister Carl Sargeant.<\/p>\n These connections made it almost inevitable that the vilification of Anne Greagsby would extend beyond Plaid Cymru. One Labourite who got involved with what was clearly an internal Plaid Cymru disciplinary procedure was Lu Thomas who tweets as @lu_luthomas<\/a>.<\/p>\n Like most zealots Lu Thomas paints the blackest possible picture of those who oppose her. Writing on the Pride Cymru website<\/a> Lu Thomas has this to say:<\/p>\n “They believe that providing gender neutral toilets or allowing our trans kids to use the facilities that reflect their true selves will mean that our girls are going to be the victims of sexual assaults. \u00a0<\/em><\/strong><\/span><\/p>\n They believe that trans people are perverts, mentally unstable sexual predators that are only transitioning to attack women in women-only spaces. \u00a0<\/em><\/strong><\/span><\/p>\n They do not accept that trans women are women. \u00a0They wish to exclude. To ridicule, to diminish and to deny trans people\u2019s rights to exist.”<\/em><\/strong><\/span><\/p>\n “They!” “They!!” “They!!!”<\/strong><\/em><\/span><\/p>\n And note the build-up to the climactic suggestion of what I can only assume to be extermination, maybe gas chambers! How OTT can one go?<\/p>\n Yet I – Jac the ‘broflake’ (\u00a9 M Shrewsbury), gammon, transphobe, etc., etc<\/em> – don’t subscribe to any<\/em> of the beliefs or attitudes listed by Lu Thomas. If a man wants to live his life as a woman, that’s fine by me. But he cannot be legally and in other ways regarded as a woman while he remains in possession of male genitalia.<\/p>\n That’s it. That’s the bottom line.<\/p>\n I don’t know Lu Thomas, I don’t even know whether Lu Thomas is a man or a woman, and I don’t care. But what I might care about if I was a member of Plaid Cymru is how Labour Party supporters and officials are able to exert influence in Plaid Cymru through niche politics and other openings.<\/p>\n Linkages that only work one way. I say that because you can be sure as hell that the obsessives don’t exert the same influence within the Labour Party. Nor have they diverted the Labour Party from its core policies and its raison d’\u00eatre<\/em> to anything like the same degree.<\/p>\n The test for Adam Price now is how he deals with the genitocentric fanatics and the hard left that kept Leanne Wood in power. If these continue to wield influence within the party, then Adam Price will have failed those who voted for him, and for a return to nationalist rather than niche politics.<\/p>\n \u2666 end\u00a0\u2666<\/strong><\/span><\/p>\n P.S.<\/strong> Soon after I put out this post someone linked me with this WalesOnline report mentioning Lu Thomas<\/a>. She and her wife Charlie, plus their twins, live in a nice family home worth over half a million quid, yet somehow they manage to rent it out on AirBnB for \u00a3500 a night.<\/p>\n Where do they live when they rent it out? Never mind, Lu is described as a “public policy consultant”<\/em>;\u00a0in other words, someone minting it from exploiting their political connections. The parasite class of Cardiff Bay.<\/p>\n UPDATE 03.10.2018:<\/strong><\/span>\u00a0WalesOnline described Louise Thomas as a ‘public policy consultant’, which I guess refers to the company she runs with another Labour time-server, and mayor of Penarth, Jon Luxton<\/a>, called Cognition Training Ltd. Alas, they have had to ask Companies House to strike the company off due to its debts<\/a>.<\/p>\n Makes you wonder, don’t it. Even with all their Labour and third sector connections these two can’t keep a little company afloat, yet they expect us to believe that their party can run our country.<\/p>\n But don’t you worry, because just like the businessmen they revile, closing down one company offers the opportunity to start up another with a very similar name, Cognition Associates Ltd. The website is under construction<\/a> and they haven’t yet got around to registering with Companies House.<\/p>\n UPDATE 05.03.2019:<\/strong><\/span> The Cognition Associates Ltd website is still under construction, and still unknown to Companies House. I hope it was nothing I said!<\/p>\n","protected":false},"excerpt":{"rendered":" THE PERSECUTION OF ANNE GREAGSBY On September 22 Anne Greagsby appeared before a Plaid Cymru disciplinary panel charged with transphobia and abusive language against certain ‘trans’ people. The accusations were made by various Plaid members and officials including Mari Arthur, Mabli Jones and Emyr Gruffydd. Mabli Jones had until quite recently worked for or with\u00a0Stonewall. … <\/p>\n![\"\"](\"https:\/\/jacothenorth.net\/blog\/wp-content\/uploads\/2018\/10\/Anne-Greagsby.jpg\")
<\/a>![\"\"](\"https:\/\/jacothenorth.net\/blog\/wp-content\/uploads\/2018\/10\/Anne-Greagsby-Gwyn-Hopkins.png\")
<\/a>![\"\"](\"https:\/\/jacothenorth.net\/blog\/wp-content\/uploads\/2018\/10\/Martyn-Shrewsbury.jpg\")
<\/a>![\"\"](\"https:\/\/jacothenorth.net\/blog\/wp-content\/uploads\/2018\/10\/Adam-Price.jpg\")
<\/a>![\"\"](\"https:\/\/jacothenorth.net\/blog\/wp-content\/uploads\/2018\/10\/Luthomas.png\")
<\/a>